The Setup

The rain hadn't let up on the office window, and neither had the argument. Tyler Perry, the new gumshoe TKDWN Media hired off the street for his eye on the middleweights and the middle ground, sat across from Jesse Smith, who'd seen enough Fargo brackets and Super 32 finals to fill a filing cabinet twice over.

Between them: fourteen weight classes, one hypothetical Who's Number One card, and a bottle of something neither man could afford. This was their first joint byline. Welcome to the racket, Tyler.

Weight File · 106 Pounds

106 Pounds

Tyler
I'll take Kooper Deputy against Nelson Villafane, and I won't apologize for it. Deputy's a PIAA champ, a Super 32 finalist, and he just went fifth at U17 Worlds — that's a resume, not a rumor.
Jesse
Deputy's already halfway out the door to 113 by the time this show goes on, pal. I want a round robin: Villafane, Rylen Wax, and Cyrus Millage. It's a circle of revenge. Wax beat Millage, Millage beat Villafane, Villafane beat Wax for the world title. That's not a match — that's a ghost story.

Weight File · 113 Pounds

113 Pounds

Tyler
Ariah Mills versus Michael Bernabe, if the fates allow it. Mills is the two-time world hardware guy, dominant before the injury took the spot from him. If he's cleared, there's no other conversation to have.
Jesse
And if Mills isn't cleared, neither is Deputy for this argument. I'd drop down to Evan Restivo, Bernabe, and Analu Woode. Restivo already owns a win over Bernabe, and Bernabe and Woode just took Fargo at different ages. Let the understudies read for the part.

Weight File · 120 Pounds

120 Pounds

Tyler
Jovanni Tovar and Caleb Noble. Tovar gave up one point all tournament at Worlds. But Noble — a three-time Illinois champ, who beat Ariah Mills back in '28 — deserves a seat at this table even after a quiet summer.
Jesse
I'm bringing back Jorge Rios for one last dance if his body allows it. He was number one before he vanished. After that it's anybody's alley: Tovar, Chase Karenbauer, Brayden Wenrich, and Mikey Batista. No clear king this year, so let the dice roll.

Weight File · 126 Pounds

126 Pounds

Tyler
This one doesn't need my help. Sammy Sanchez, Grey Burnett, and Landon Sidun — three deep in a round robin. Everybody from Matscouts to Flo's been talking about it for a reason.
Jesse
Who? We don't talk about those outfits, pal. But — Sanchez the two-time world champ, Burnett the runner-up in Vegas, Sidun defending last year's crown. This is the marquee of the whole card.

Weight File · 132 Pounds

132 Pounds

Tyler
Paul Kenny and Freddie Bachmann. Fargo runner-up against a fellow Iowa commit. Clean one and two, no debate needed.
Jesse
Same pick, same reasons, sweetheart. I like the poetry of it. Future Hawkeye roommates settling business before they're teammates.

Weight File · 138 Pounds

138 Pounds

Tyler
Israel Borge and Dean Anderson. Borge already beat him by tech last year, and Anderson's been busy this summer with a Pan Am title to his name.
Jesse
I'd swap in Dawson Youngblut for Anderson if I'm being honest with myself. I don't rank the Valiant kids in-season. But Flo runs this show, and Flo ranks everybody who's still breathing, so I'll allow it.

Weight File · 144 Pounds

144 Pounds

Tyler
Jesse Grajeda's the easy invite. A California state and Fargo champ this year. He beat a stacked Fargo bracket to get there, and Dale Corbin was in that bracket.
Jesse
Grajeda's a lock, no argument. But let Corbin and Gavin Mangano fight for the privilege first. Mangano's simply done more at the weight lately. Also Braylon Reynolds should get a look too.

Weight File · 150 Pounds

150 Pounds

Tyler
Clinton Shepherd and Jason Dube. Run back the Fargo quarterfinal Dube stole 7-6. Shepherd's still the resume king even after the DNP shocker.
Jesse
Same match, but I'm watching the exits. If Shepherd bolts for the NLWC early like some before him, I'd maybe let Illia Kyrianenko defend his own Fargo crown instead.

Weight File · 157 Pounds

157 Pounds

Tyler
Cam Howard and Mac Crosson. Crosson beat him at U20 World Team Trials this summer, and that's a fresh enough wound to fill a card.
Jesse
I'm adding a third — Michael Romero, if he's really settled at 157. Then it's Crosson v Howard running back their trials bout, Romero crashes the party.

Weight File · 165 Pounds

165 Pounds

Tyler
Melvin Miller and Rocco Cassioppi — this is a straight rematch of the Fargo final. Miller's resume speaks for itself at this point.
Jesse
I'd give Miller the bye this time and let Bachmann take a crack at Cassioppi instead. The kid's earned a folkstyle shot, and Miller's earned the right to sit out until a winner is decided.

Weight File · 175 Pounds

175 Pounds

Tyler
Zack Aquila and Justus Heeg. Aquila knocked off a gauntlet at Fargo, but Heeg's the sleeper — Super 32 champ, Ironman runner-up. He hasn't lost his edge just because he was hurt through the summer.
Jesse
I want the whole cast for this one: Aquila versus Jayden O'Farrill, Mario Carini versus Heeg. Too much talent at this weight to waste on a single bout.

Weight File · 190 Pounds

190 Pounds

Tyler
Salah Tsarni and Nick Singer. Tsarni's summer resume — U17 silver, Super 32 and Ironman placements — makes him the man to beat.
Jesse
No disagreement, but I'd throw Mario Hutcherson at Singer first. Winner earns the shot at Tsarni. Make them work for the marquee.

Weight File · 215 Pounds

215 Pounds

Tyler
Jimmy Mastny and Michael Boyle. This would be the matchup of the night — full stop. Both fresh off U20 Worlds, both champions in their own right.
Jesse
Can't argue, though it's a shame football season's got Boyle all to itself through November. In this world — my world — we make him show up anyway.

Weight File · 285 Pounds

285 Pounds

Tyler
Lukas Zalota and Kam Hazelett. Zalota's the National Preps and Beast of the East champ; Hazelett's the wounded warrior who was second at Super 32 before injury caught up to him.
Jesse
I want Cael Mielnik and Brydon Feister to open the door — winner gets Zalota. Feister might be the best prospect nobody's fully seen yet. This would be his stage to prove it.

The rain kept falling outside the TKDWN offices, but the card was set. Fourteen weights, twenty-eight opinions, one new voice in the room. Tyler's earned his desk lamp.